Map by Reddit user Trenavix
This fascinating map reveals something most people don’t realize: where you live within North America (in particular, the United States and Canada) matters far more for your quality of life than which country you call home.
The Human Development Index (HDI) measures three key factors: life expectancy, education levels, and income per capita. What emerges is a complex patchwork that defies simple national stereotypes.
Canada’s Consistent Excellence
Canada’s provinces dominate the upper tiers of human development, with Alberta leading at an impressive 0.955 HDI score. This oil-rich province benefits from high incomes, excellent healthcare, and strong educational systems.
Most Canadian provinces cluster in the 0.930-0.949 range, showing remarkable consistency across this vast nation. Even Canada’s lowest-performing regions significantly outpace many American states.
America’s Tale of Two Nations
The United States presents a starkly different picture. While states like Massachusetts, Connecticut, and New York achieve HDI scores comparable to top Canadian provinces, the American South tells another story entirely.
Mississippi anchors the bottom at 0.866, a score that would place it among developing nations globally. This represents a gap of nearly 0.1 HDI points between America’s best and worst performing states.
The Great Divide Explained
Several factors explain these dramatic differences.
Southern states historically struggle with lower educational attainment, shorter life expectancies often linked to health challenges, and economic structures that haven’t fully transitioned from their agricultural past. Meanwhile, northeastern states and certain western regions benefit from knowledge economies, better healthcare infrastructure, and higher median incomes.
Geography plays a role, too. States with major metropolitan areas, research universities, and diverse economies tend to perform better. Rural areas, regardless of country, face unique challenges in delivering services and economic opportunities that boost HDI scores.
What This Means for You
This data challenges the assumption that national citizenship determines quality of life.
A resident of rural Mississippi faces significantly different life prospects than someone in urban Massachusetts, despite sharing the same passport. Similarly, someone in Newfoundland enjoys higher human development metrics than residents of several American states.
The map also highlights policy impacts. Canada’s universal healthcare system likely contributes to more consistent outcomes across provinces, while America’s state-by-state approach to education, healthcare, and social services creates wider variation.
Looking Forward
These patterns aren’t permanent. States and provinces can improve their HDI scores through targeted investments in education, healthcare, and economic development. The question becomes: will political leaders use this data to address inequalities, or will these gaps persist and potentially widen?
Understanding these regional differences helps explain everything from migration patterns to political divisions, reminding us that in North America, your postal code might matter more than your passport.
Help us out by sharing this map: